Thirty-Six Dramatic Situations
	Author: Georges Polti Published: 2003-03-10
	List price: $22.95 Our price: $17.90	Usually ships in 24 hours As of: September 03rd, 2010 09:31:39 PM
Customer comments on this selection. Still Useful Albeit Somewhat Obsolete I found Polti's "Les trente-six situations dramatiques" with another classic of his, "L'art d'inventer les personnages" reprinted by Éditions d'aujourd'hui in a serie called "Les introuvables" and I can assure you that both books are very difficult to find as genuine originals. Now Lucille Ray has made a tour de force and Thirty-Six Dramatic Situations is available to English speaking readers. Polti claims that all dramatic situations boil down to only 36 basic situations. You can believe him or not but much what he says makes sense and he supports his claim by giving examples from classic literature. He also refers to novels and stories which may be difficult to find but the point is that somebody has used the dramatic situation in question and there may be others. This is the true value of Polti, if you truly want to offer your readers something new and don't want to copy your ideas from published novels. The other side of the coin is that certain dramatic situations can be safely used over and over again because the public wants you to play the same old song again and again. I like to read Polti's ideas just for fun and only regret that many of the books he refers to are difficult to find. Some of them are also available only in French. There must be some well-read amateur who could write an English version of Polti's book and give examples based on English texts. I guarantee a huge success. The same goes for The Art Of Inventing Characters. Anybody for the money and fame? OK, what about the moneyThe Thirty-Six Dramatic Situations? Know What's Inside This text comes highly recommended as a classic by far too many creative writing and screenwriting teachers. Want to know if this book is for you? Read this passage: "In the second, by means of a contraction analogous to that which abbreviates a syllogism to an enthymeme, this undecided power is but an attribute of the persecutor himself." The entire book reads this way, so if that works for ya, you'll love this book. If it doesn't, you'll need to look elsewhere. A Useful Reference I don't quite understand how Polti came to classify the plots in this book the way he did. It made little sense to me. Nevertheless, I do see it as a useful reference for writers stuck for ideas. For my own part, I was able to think of some ideas which Polti did not seem to cover, even when I thought of his classifications as 'general categories', umbrellas under which every conceivable plot could fall. Don't take the red pill Neo! This is the pool of Siloam. If you wish to remain in that happy blissful world of suspended disbelief, where fairy stories continue to charm and inspire, and heroes are held sacred, then by all means never read this book. "He spat on the ground, and made clay of the spittle, and applied the clay to his eyes, and said to him, "Go, wash in the pool of Siloam" (which is translated, Sent). So he went away and washed, and came back seeing." Gospel of John: 9: 6-7. The intended audience of this work: the permanently cynical (me), writers, and English Literature undergraduates. For undergrads: after mentioning Foucault you quote Polti's structural plot diagnostic in some obfuscated sentence in about your third paragraph of any lit paper and you're on your way to graduating with honors. Heck, you professor won't even read any further and just slap an "A" on the darn thing. For writers: if you are stuck, reading this will send you screaming back to your alphanumeric clavichord faster than a Mustang with a tank full of white lightening and jet fuel. One of the horrible things about reviewing is you start to think about what you've seen and read. Given man's continued Aristotelian imperative to classify, we also begin to classify written and visual literature. Soon this is distilled to an essence, and soon you read the essence instead of the story. Or the familiar story is re-written in a disguised way, and with such excellent selection of language, you don't care. Georges Polti made things even worse than Aristotle did, and now there are no new stories under the sun. Instead of a Novel-O-Matic or "Mad-Lib: The Novel" we have Polti's "The Thirty-Six Dramatic Situations." Read this and you need never read again, but will always just flip to this most essential of the "Master Plots." Why 36? Why not. Nice factoring on that handy number, sounds plausible, and didn't Jesus die at 36 years old? Or was it 33? Aren't there "Form Critics" and deconstructionists who hold the Gospels out to be the first novels? Polti hesitates not. Excellent -- yet not what it's cracked up to be This book is famous mostly among people who have only heard of it. People who have actually read it are less gushy with their praise. Most folks think of this as a book of all the different plots and their variations. But personally, I prefer to look at the title itself, which speaks not of "plots" but of "dramatic situations". Picture a story as if it were a play. When the curtain rises, the actors are all on stage and frozen in a tableau that displays their roles and inter-relationships. It is Polti's contention that these tableaus, or "dramatic situations", amount to no more than 36 in number. How does this differ from 36 plots? Well, there may be only a limited number of relationships among the characters when the curtain first rises, but there are a zillion different ways in which those relationships can play themselves out. In Polti's sub-headings he goes through a wide range of different variations. So if you're looking for a one-size-fits-all set of plotlines so that you can write your blockbuster, forget it. If you want a densely written analysis of the 36 Dramatic Situations, this is your book. The book will help writers think about their craft, but it's still not as simple as people make it sound when they describe the book over a beer. One problem that I ran into was Polti's era and nationality. He was a Frenchman writing almost a hundred years ago. As a result, his voluminous notations describing a plethora of literary examples was mainly lost on me. Unless you're an expert on 19th Century French theatre, you may find yourself in the same boat. My bottom line: this is a good book. I'm glad I've got it and I occasionaslly pull it off the shelf and re-read sections. But is it a masterpiece, the Holy Grail of plot-writers? No.
Our Health Care book picks:
Health care needs of aging adults: unprecedented opportunities for social work.(Editorial): An article from: Health and Social Work First Aid for the® Medicine Clerkship: Second Edition (First Aid Series) First Aid for the NBDE Part II (First Aid Series) (Pt. 2) Advanced First Aid Afloat First Responder: A Skills Approach (7th Edition)

Disclaimer:
This site does not treat, diagnose or assess medical conditions. We do not prescribe medication or provide medical advice. The opinions, information and resources contained within this site are for informational purposes only. This information is not medical practice nor medical advice. Before starting any type of medical progam, exercise program, change in lifestyle, or diet, consult your physician to determine the options best suited to your individual needs.